Two Toffee Gifts, One Clear Difference
Both Compartes toffee gifts trace back to a recipe from 1950, but they are not the same product in different packaging. The English Toffee Gift Box comes in Medium and Large sizes at $44.80 and $64.00 respectively, while the Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box is a single standard size at $27.72. The names sound similar, yet the size options and price points point to different gifting situations.
If you need a larger box for a family or a office gift, the English Toffee Gift Box gives you a size choice. If you want a smaller, ready-to-give box with a distinctive gold-foiled presentation, the Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box may fit better. The rest of this comparison breaks down what the catalog confirms and what it leaves open.
What the Catalog Confirms About Each Box
- English Toffee Gift Box: English Toffee Gift Box is available in Medium and Large sizes, priced at $44.80 and $64.00. Size options let you match the gift to the number of recipients or the occasion.

English Toffee Gift Box - English Toffee Gift Box: Homemade from brown sugar and butter, hand dipped in premium chocolate, and rolled in chopped roasted almonds. These ingredients define the classic butter toffee experience and clarify that chocolate is part of the recipe.
- Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box: Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box is a standard-size box priced at $27.72. A single, lower-priced option suits smaller gifts or budget-conscious shoppers.

Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box - Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box: Comes in a new gold-foiled gift box and features the time-honored recipe since 1950 with brown sugar, roasted almonds, and premium chocolate. The gold-foiled box signals a more formal presentation, useful when the gift is the centerpiece.
Side-by-Side: Size, Price, and Presentation
The English Toffee Gift Box offers two sizes, while the Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box comes in one standard size. The per-box price is lower for the chocolate covered version, but the English Toffee Gift Box provides more volume in its Large size. Presentation also differs: the chocolate covered box is explicitly described as gold-foiled, whereas the English Toffee Gift Box description does not mention foil or a specific box finish.
- English Toffee Gift Box: Medium $44.80; Large $64.00. Two size choices. No gold-foil detail in the supplied description.
- Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box: Standard size $27.72. One size only. Gold-foiled gift box is a stated feature.
Butter Toffee vs Chocolate Toffee: Is the Recipe Different?
The names suggest a distinction, but the catalog does not describe two separate recipes. The English Toffee Gift Box is made from brown sugar and butter, hand dipped in premium chocolate, and rolled in chopped roasted almonds. The Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box uses the same time-honored recipe since 1950 with brown sugar, roasted almonds, and premium chocolate. In both cases, chocolate is part of the toffee, not an optional coating.
That means you are not choosing between plain toffee and chocolate-covered toffee. You are choosing between two gift formats of a chocolate-dipped almond toffee. The real differences are size, price, and packaging, not a fundamentally different flavor.
Which Box Suits Which Gift?
- For a larger household or office gift: Choose the English Toffee Gift Box in Large ($64.00) or Medium ($44.80) when you want more to share.
- For a smaller, budget-friendly gift: Choose the Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box at $27.72 when one standard box is enough.
- For a presentation-focused gift: Choose the Chocolate Covered English Toffee Gift Box if the gold-foiled box is important to you.
- For a chocolate lover who enjoys options: Choose the English Toffee Gift Box if you want to select a size that matches the recipient's household.
What the Catalog Does Not Confirm
The supplied records do not state allergen information, shelf life, or storage instructions for either box. They also do not confirm whether the English Toffee Gift Box comes in a gold-foiled box or whether either product is suitable for specific dietary needs. If these details matter for your gift, check the full product page or contact the store before ordering. The absence of this information in the catalog is not evidence that the products lack certain features; it simply means those details are not available here.



